My friends, yes, Lent is upon us once again. For some, just mention of the word brings up negative feelings – for others, Lent may be about “inviting” a “welcome” time of 40 Days into your life to look more introspectively, trying to see, as we reflect each week during Mass, “if we have been the people that Jesus calls us to be.” So, wherever you may be on the continuum of “yah to nah” on Lent, let’s start there.
As always, let’s begin with the chosen readings for today: You know from previous homilies that for the most part, I always stick to the chosen readings because I want us to be in step with our Universal Church. And even when it is the case that the readings aren’t that good, as with the 1st two for today, it is a place to start and we can then go further.
Take the first reading from Genesis today—did anyone other than me think it strange that we start out with the “earth creature” whom we assume from other translations to be Adam, enjoying the beauties of the garden that God has created, and then the jump of a chapter to introduce the woman just in time to bring “sin” into the world?
Granted, “our sinfulness” is what is trying to be lifted up throughout the readings, but I also suspect that the ages-old tendency, “to blame the woman” is afoot here as well, even though in a few lines not included in this reading, we hear that God put the “earth creature” to sleep and divided it into [equal parts], creating male and female entities. So, this tendency, “to blame the woman” even though, a subtle thing, in a patriarchal culture, is one to note just the same.
Then, moving into the 2nd reading from Paul to the Romans – in my mind, he protests too much. His intent in preaching to the Romans who knew little or nothing of Jesus, was no doubt to have them get a clear picture of who Jesus was, but I for one, object to the picture he is portraying here. Why does the act of making a human choice have to be carried on through all of humanity and their history, in order that Jesus can then come and save us from ourselves? This is faulty reasoning if we are to believe in the graciousness and mercy of God.
It is probably this reading where the notion of original sin comes from, and the need for God—and not a loving God, at that, to be appeased through the death of Jesus. This so-called “theology” is so flawed, as it makes God so small-minded, so small-hearted, as Sister Joan Chittister would say of such theology, so vindictive—more like us than God, who in other places—we are told, “is all-loving and all-merciful.” Theologian, Sister Sandra Schneiders speaks of Jesus’ God, thus, “God was not only compassionate, but compassion itself.” We can’t believe both narratives—that of a vindictive God and that of an all-loving, all-understanding God—as in the God of the “Prodigal,” a story of over-the-top love which we will read later on in Lent.
Then, we have the gospel from Matthew that you will recall is all about Jesus’ “temptations to power,” as he prepares for his public ministry. Anyone called to leadership will always be tempted by the power that can come with the role. Jesus is aware of this and thus tries to make himself strong through fasting and prayer, in order to avoid this very strong temptation and keep focused on his mission.
Fasting from food, as all “good Catholics” are counseled to do during Lent, has its place in our lives if it prepares us to better focus on moving out of ourselves to see the needs of others, to in fact be better people. I personally tend, as you know, to shy away from fasting as prescribed by the Church during Lent as I can’t seem to separate it from the notion of “dieting” and this conundrum was validated for me a few years back in a piece that I read in the National Catholic Reporter (NCR) on fasting and the different take that many women have on the topic. Of course, this article was written by a woman!
Because many women have grown up with the false impression, created by our male-centered culture, that women are only acceptable if they have a certain body type and shape, fasting takes on a whole different notion for women than it does for men, the writer said. There is a reason friends, why more women than men, in our culture, suffer from anorexia and bulimia.
The men in charge, the writer continues, say that you can’t unite the two, that is, using a time of fasting to lose a few extra pounds. And that is why I have stopped trying. If I happen to be dieting during Lent, (when am I not trying to lose those extra pounds?!), I call it “dieting” and forget about fasting, for what that is worth.
So, let’s take what we have here and go deeper, as we are always called to do. The Church hierarchy wants us to get the notion, and never forget it, “that we are a sinful people, mea culpa, mea culpa,” thus the 1st two readings from Genesis and Romans. I spoke of my objections to both readings from the way in Genesis that the message is parsed out, emphasizing the “woman” as the chief sinner, and in the 2nd reading where Paul lays out the “apparent need” that this “original” sin be passed on through all of our human history, so that every newborn baby coming into our “Catholic” world is considered “sin” instead of “blessing” as the Creator intended.
Again, this is a time to let God be God, and not create a God that appears like us, mean and despicable at times. As I said above, later on in Lent, we will read of a “Prodigal God” who will always “run to meet us” when we “want to come home.”
So, what are we to do with these 40 Days? If the counsel to “fast and pray and give alms,” as our bishop apparently suggests, not even connected to any of the injustices in our society, doesn’t quite do it for us, how shall we observe this time and make it meaningful? As we suggested last week in discussing the commandment, “that we not kill,” there are many ways to “kill” – through words and inaction, there are also many ways to “fast.”
But 1st off, I must say, if fasting from food helps you to grow closer to Jesus and live in our world as he did in his, speaking truth to power, and advocating for “the least among us,” I am not discouraging it, but if it simply leaves you with an “ugh” feeling, then you may want to “fast” in a different way: you can fast perhaps from nagging a loved one, or from using your sharp tongue, tone, or wit to denigrate another, or from selfishness with your time, or from judgmentalism, or snobbishness, or the need to have things done your way, and the list can go on. I am sure we can each find ourselves somewhere in that list.
And in the end, if we don’t come out on the other side of Lent knowing that we are mightily loved by our God, flawed as we are, then, I would think we had missed something important. When you really look at Jesus’ earthly life, you have to conclude that he was an astounding person, and to follow in his ways—actions and words—we certainly could do worse! He was one who saw the goodness of his Abba in all he met and continually worked for the good of all—he saw all as, “his Body and Blood—the eucharist, in the best sense of that word…and so should we.
So, my friends, I hope that I have instilled today the notion, that “religious practices,” fasting, prayer and almsgiving, “set on a shelf,” as it were, apart from our lives – our day in and day out encounters with the Christ, in the humanity of all who come into our lives, kind of misses the point. Lent isn’t intended to be a feat to be accomplished, but as a path forward.
And we do need to be strong to respond as Pastor Chad Ellenburg of Pleasant Valley church did with his community last Sunday here in Winona. Keeping in mind that his community, unlike in traditional Catholic churches, can fire him if they don’t like the message he is preaching, what he had to say was quite astounding and prophetic. I shared the link to his homily earlier in the week, and if you haven’t yet listened to it, I would encourage you to do so. We should pray for each other that we could have such strength. One of the lines he gave in addressing why he felt he needed to connect the Scriptures to all that is happening in our world, was this: He said, “I don’t want to be late on this!”
And let’s pray for our world and each other that we can more often remember that we came into this world as “blessings” and must strive to be a blessing to all we meet. If we do that on a regular basis, I think we can consider humbly not only “Lenten Days,” but most days of our lives successful! Amen? Amen!
______________________________________
And with that spirit in mind, I would invite you, if you wish, to come up to receive ashes, remembering that “We have come from the good earth, and will return there one day.” This beautiful Lenten ritual should help us remember our place among all created life in our world.
You must be logged in to post a comment.