News Item–Letter to the USCCB on Abuse

Dear Friends, 

Here is a letter to the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops penned by the Roman Catholic Woman Priests organization on the issue of abuse–as your pastor, I added my name to the letter in the name of All Are One Roman Catholic church. 


 

“For they preach but they do not practice. They tie up heavy burdens and lay them on people’s shoulders, but they will not lift a finger to move them.” (Matthew 23)

There has been no historical moment more pivotal for the Catholic Church in the United States than today. The Pennsylvania Grand Jury’s report and allegations against Theodore McCarrick among other incidents irrefutably prove widespread, decades-long, systematic efforts to hide sexual abuse by clergy and religious.

In our work as theologians and pastoral ministers, we hear firsthand the anguished cries of God’s suffering people and witness the evils which plague our Church. Compelled by survivors’ accounts of life-destroying violence, we exercise our right and responsibility to speak out “on those things which concern the good of the Church” such that “the whole Church, strengthened by each one of its members, may more effectively fulfill its mission for the life of the world” (Lumen Gentium 37).

The establishment of justice in the Church requires more than apologies, investigations, and bureaucratic reforms now being proposed by the very episcopal institution responsible for this crisis. True justice and authentic reconciliation demands a sweeping and deep renewal among the People of God that arises from the prophetic teachings of Vatican II and proceeds through the pastoral vision of Pope Francis. Let us offer three points towards that end.

First, we disagree with the view held by some Catholics that sexual abuse and its cover up result from a failure to adhere to existing magisterial teachings on sexuality. Bishops must honestly confront the reality that many, if not most, of the current teachings on sexuality and gender are too often barriers to holiness. Damning words about lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, and intersex people, for example, perpetuate dated and disproven narratives that contribute to and reinforce prejudiced attitudes and unjust structures. Likewise, gay and bisexual clergy are not the cause of these problems. It is rather the inability to speak in honest and healthy ways about sexuality, coupled with homophobia, that fosters a culture of secrecy and silence where abuse goes unchecked.

Second, misguided teachings on sexuality and gender are only some of the rotten fruits exuding from a profoundly sick institution. Sanctioned patriarchy denies women’s dignity, rejects their gifts, and undergirds misguided approaches to sexuality and gender. Clericalism fortifies a corrupted hierarchy that affords clerics unbridled power while suppressing lay co-responsibility. Racism, ableism, colonialism, and other unjust power dynamics infect every crevice of this Church we love. Each of these rotten fruits is grounded in the failure to implement more boldly Vatican II’s teachings on Church structures, authority, and contemporary mission.

Third, it is past time to throw open the windows of the U.S. Church. To end cycles of sexual abuse and cover ups, and to restore faith in the Church, we, as loving critics and critical lovers of the People of God, offer the following suggestions to our bishops:

  • Submit a letter of resignation to Pope Francis immediately;
  • Demand the Vatican make available to U.S. civil authorities all relevant documents on sexual abuse by clergy and religious;
  • Establish truth and reconciliation commissions to address abuses and cover ups honestly and openly, and include survivors in leadership positions;
  • Publish a collective statement which both supports gay/bisexual priests and clearly articulates that homosexuality is not a cause of abuse and sexual violence;
  • Support civil government efforts to extend statutes of limitation;
  • Make public in each diocese the financial amount which has been paid out in settlements and legal costs related to sexual abuse;
  • Provide liturgies for healing which are developed and celebrated by lay ministers and leaders in collaboration with survivors;
  • Host listening sessions on topics including survivor justice, structural reform, and sexuality at the diocesan and parish levels which include the bishop and key pastoral leaders;
  • Engage Catholic voices and organizations which have a longstanding commitment to and specialization in church reform, accountability, and survivor support;
  • Convene theologians and canon lawyers to develop the theological tools necessary for a more thorough response to sexual abuse and for the Church’s renewal in the United States, which may include consideration of alternative parish and diocesan leadership models where women are in leadership positions;
  • Create policies to remove immediately all titles, honors, and memorials from bishops, clergy, and religious who have been credibly accused of being involved in abuse, sexual violence, and/or its cover up;
  • Invite consultative lay participation in the selection of bishops;
  • Ensure robust lay involvement and especially leadership throughout processes of creating justice, accountability, and reconciliation.

The challenges before the Catholic Church in the United States are not insurmountable, but overcoming them is not inevitable. Learning from history, we know that too many times the faithful have been silent about, indifferent to, and even complicit in humanity’s worst crimes. We must not repeat these failings today.

The time of necessary action is now and the task is urgent. We implore you, as siblings in Christ and as co-workers in the vineyard, to be accountable to and transparent with the entire People of God, to seek true renewal inspired by Vatican II that goes beyond cosmetic institutional reforms, and to follow Pope Francis in practicing a radical discipleship.

Bulletin – 20th Week in Ordinary Time

Dear Friends,

Mass on Saturday, August 18, 2018 at 4:30 P.M. 


Remember our weekly collection of groceries for the Winona Volunteer Services food shelf


We continue this week to make sense in our lives of the call, “to be bread” in our world in the footsteps of our brother, Jesus.

Come; be with us as we ponder just how to do this!

Peace and love,

Pastor Kathy


Readings:

  • Proverbs 9: 1-6
  • Ephesians 5: 15-20
  • John 6: 48-58

All Are One Roman Catholic Church Safety Policy

 Every effort will be made to ensure the safety of all attendees at All Are One services and social activities.  Any violation of this policy will be reported immediately to local law enforcement.

(This statement was updated and reviewed with the Board of All Are One Roman Catholic church at the July 2, 2018 board meeting).


 

Homily – 19th Sunday in Ordinary Time

My friends, once again, we continue this week to ponder Jesus, our brother, as the “bread of life.”  He tells us in John’s gospel that if we eat of this “bread” that he gives; we shall never die.  Now of course; we know that he isn’t speaking about our physical deaths, but our spiritual deaths, a death none of us, as his followers wants to experience.

In one of Jesus’ other sayings, he went on to expound, “I want you to have life and life in abundance!” Jesus, as we know, was always about “turning things on their heads,” so to speak, asking us to be counter culture, especially when, “following the crowd,” was demonstrative of fear, selfishness and safety, as opposed to openness, mercy, risk-taking for the good of all—simply put, the law to love.   And in this law to love, our own life is lived to the fullest.

The adjoining readings for this 19th Sunday are instructive as well in how we should attempt to live out, the law to love.  We get a sense of the “bread of life” in each one and as last week, see that the “bread” we are called to give, can be physical, spiritual or emotional.

Elijah the prophet, in the first reading from Kings; we find in somewhat of a depressed state—he has been ministering for his God and is tired—bone-tired and wondering whether physical death might be a better option than what his life is at present.  We see his God responding as God always responds; with care and with love—one just has to have eyes to see! Elijah, through an angel is given food and water and rest, not only once, but twice and it is our God’s constant care that allows Elijah to continue his ministry.

Looking toward ourselves; we might say the same is true.  Our care for others must always include ourselves.  I practiced my advice this week by taking a day and a half at Assisi Heights for a mini retreat.  It was very good just to “hole up” as it were, have quiet time for reading and reflecting and I came away with gratitude for all the gifts of my life, as well as being renewed to continue all that God has in store.

Paul, in the second reading to the Ephesians simply tells us to spend no time on the negative emotions:  bitterness, rage, anger, or the negative actions of harsh, slanderous words and all other kinds of malice. We are instead instructed to be kind, compassionate and forgiving.  Simple to write down, yes, not always simple to do!

I read an interesting article this past week in the National Catholic Reporter in the Young Voices section.  The article was commenting on a new book, entitled, Daring Greatly, by Brene Brown wherein she argues that we should follow Jesus’ lead and become vulnerable.  She makes the point of saying that “being vulnerable” is not being weak as some might think.  Being vulnerable is being willing to say that you don’t have all the answers and being equally willing to listen to another’s thought or opinion to get closer to the truth for all of us.

Paul, in his letter to the Ephesians seems to be saying that we have to trust more that laying our hearts open as Jesus did will bring about the hoped for result quicker and more amiably than the alternative choice. In other words; we have to “walk in love” as did Jesus.

And for those who aren’t risk-takers, “question-askers,” or are satisfied to make-no-waves; the temptation to criticize those who do take risks, ask questions and make waves will always seem a viable choice.  It was so for Jesus as we saw in the gospel today, and it will be so for us too—“we know your mother and father,”—how dare you claim to be more than you are?

Most of you are aware that the Rochester Franciscan Sisters elected new leadership recently.  At their installation ceremony on July 1 each of the new community ministers reflected on one particular word from their chosen theme for their time in leadership, “Living from our common heart.”  For my purposes today; I will comment on just two of the reflections.

First, Sr. Jennifer Corbett reflected on the word, “from” in her comments.  She spoke of coming “from” South Bend, Indiana, that her father was “from” American Irish descent and that her mother came “from” France.  Additionally, she mentioned that she has an older sister, Mary, and a brother, Phil.  She stated that this is “her tribe,” so to speak, and that with these pieces of information; we might come to some conclusions about her, right or wrong, just as the people in Jesus’ time did about him.  She goes on to say that just as he couldn’t be confined by his humble beginnings, we too can’t fail to do what God may be calling us to because we, “don’t have the voice, the strength, the position”—whatever we may come up with as excuses for not doing our part!

The second reflection comes from Sr. Mary Eliot and her comments revolve around the word, “our” as in “Living from our common heart.”  She uses the word, “our” as a jumping-off place to speak about our (Sisters and Cojourners) origins, giftedness and our future together as Franciscans, followers of Francis and Clare of Assisi and states in no uncertain terms that in order for us to do our best, what God is calling us each to, our “interconnectedness” is going to be most important.  She describes most beautifully what she means by referencing the story of The Velveteen Rabbit, by Margery Williams.

Most of us recall that this is a story of a velveteen rabbit that becomes real through the love of a little child.  In the character of the Skin Horse, who is real, the rabbit learns what it is “to be real.”  “It’s a thing that happens to you when a child loves you for a long, long time…then you become real.”

The rabbit wants to know, “does it hurt?” The skin horse answers, “Sometimes, [but] when you are real, you don’t mind being hurt.”

The skin horse goes on to say that it doesn’t happen all at once, [becoming real] and it doesn’t happen to those who “break easily,” or have “sharp edges” or have to “be carefully kept.”  And by the time you are real, “most of your hair has been loved off, your eyes drop out, you get loose in the joints and very shabby.”  The skin horse concludes by saying that “those things don’t matter…because “once you are real you can’t be ugly except to people who don’t understand.”

Mary Eliot concluded her reflection saying that for her, “to be real is to love another into being.”  My friends, each of us is called like Elijah, like Jesus, like Paul, to be real, to love each other into being through our willingness to be trusting and understanding of others, even when we disagree. We may lose “our fur” like the skin horse, become tired like Elijah, misunderstood like Jesus, but in all of this; we will have the peace of knowing that like those who came before us, we have been faithful followers of our God, of our brother Jesus.  Amen? Amen!

Bulletin – 19th Sunday in Ordinary Time

Dear Friends,

Mass on Sunday, August 12, 2018 at 10 a.m. 


Remember our weekly collection of groceries for the Winona Volunteer Services Food Shelf


We keep fine-tuning the notion of being “bread” for our world in the footsteps of our brother, Jesus. It would seem that if we eat of the “bread of life,” which is more than physical food, we will have abundant life.

Come; be with us, ponder these mysteries this week.

Peace and love,

Pastor Kathy


Readings: 

  • 1 Kings 19: 4-8
  • Ephesians 4: 30–5:2
  • John 6: 41-51

 

All Are One Roman Catholic Church Safety Policy

Every effort will be made to ensure the safety of all attendees at All Are One services and social activities.  Any violation of this policy will be reported immediately to local law enforcement.

(This statement was updated and reviewed with the Board of All Are One Roman Catholic church at the July 2, 2018 board meeting.


 

Homily – 18th Sunday of Ordinary Time

 My friends, today as last Sunday; we continue contemplating the “bread of life” whom we know to be our brother, Jesus.  We get this truth from both the Old or First Testament of the Bible in the book of Exodus and in the New Testament, in Jesus’ words—Jesus of course brings the message to completion.

Exodus tells us, “This is the bread our God has given you to eat.” In John’s gospel we hear, “You shall not be working for perishable food, but for life-giving food that lasts for all eternity.”  John continues, “Jesus is the bread that Abba God gives,” in which, “we will not be hungry or thirsty.”

Paul, in his letter to the Ephesians carves out for us, Jesus’ followers, just what following him will mean, “You must stop living the kind of life the world lives,” or in other words, our life in Jesus calls us to more! It seems to be about living, “in the justice and holiness of the truth.”

The readings for this Sunday call each of us to consider how Jesus was “bread” for his world and of how we are called to the same.  Sometimes the “bread” we are called to give is of a purely physical nature—people are physically hungry and must in justice, be fed. For us who are blessed with having enough and to spare of physical bread, the solution might appear simple—share what we have and many of us do.  The initiatives through this parish help us to do that; contributing to The Winona Volunteer Services Food Shelf, our monthly meals to Bethany Catholic Worker House and our parish’s yearly commitment of time delivering Home Meals during the month of February.

In Jesus’ life, he started at this level as well to meet people’s basic needs, but it was always about bringing them to the next level—feeding people’s minds, hearts and spirits. People—humans, our sisters and brothers need more than food for their bodies—they need the “bread” of compassion, understanding, justice in their lives—this is the “more” that was at the heart of Jesus’ message.  We can’t just stop with feeding people’s physical bodies, important as that is; but we must strive to understand why people are physically hungry, why some have more than enough and to spare and others are left wanting.

In all the times when Jesus fed physically hungry people; he gave in abundance and this was to signify the over-the-top love of his Abba God for all of creation.  God’s generosity and faithfulness through Jesus to creation was always meant to show us the way—the goods of this earth are meant for all to enjoy and whatever it is in this world that causes some of us to live well while others suffer must most assuredly be addressed by Jesus’ followers if the full kin-dom is ever to be realized.

Obviously, our world’s people are not, as Paul suggests, living as we should or we would not have people physically starving to death; we would not have countries warring with each other; we would not have half the world’s population still living under the tyranny of patriarchy both in church and state; there would be the justice that allows individuals to live fully and freely the lives that God created and called them to live.  Gender, life-style choices, religious beliefs that call individuals to different, yet unique expressions of themselves and their God would not be impediments to hold them down, but gifts to be celebrated from the God of us all—from whom we are all, “so wonderfully made.

Now this is a bit of a depressing picture that I paint, but I see great hope in our world as people are stepping up and forward to do that which is theirs to do—all those who are ministering on our southern border to say that our country stands for more than greed and arrogance, fear and selfishness—that understands people running from war and unspeakable conditions, in their own countries, risking their lives and their children’s lives to come to a land that in the past has always stood for the rights of individuals to know peace, freedom and justice in their lives.

On a local level, several interfaith communities, including our own, have said “yes” to being a part of the Sanctuary Movement here, in the pursuit of a higher law.  Every time we reach out friends, moving with our hearts rather than our heads, attempting to do what may not be safe, but what is good and right and just; we are being faithful to our brother, Jesus’ call, as his followers.

You are aware that the 15th season of the Great River Shakespeare festival in Winona finishes today.  We had the good fortune on Tuesday night to partake in the yearly production of Callithump as part of the festival.  Webster’s defines the word “callithump” as a noisy, boisterous band or parade.  The production of Callithump always comes near the end of the season of plays in order that those who have seen the separate plays will better understand the subtle jokes and spoofs presented within it.

I have always experienced this event in the past as a very fun night of the actors letting their hair down, so to speak, after all the fine work of the season and just enjoying each other as they continue to entertain their audience in a less-scripted way.

This year, there was that, but I noticed a concerted effort to uplift the women in the company expressing all their wonderful differences as individuals and most poignantly, in a final tribute to the cause of women expressed this past year in the #MeToo movement. Great River Shakespeare women flanked by all their male counterparts proclaimed their independence, their rightness to be, that, “enough was enough,” and that no matter what anyone had said or done, they were and are, terrific!

My friends, whenever any one of us is not respected, is put down for who and what they were created to be; we are all put down because we fail to be who God created us to be, who Jesus gave his life to protect, the very image of the divine.  We are all called not just to see that people receive the physical bread that they need, but the emotional and spiritual bread as well.  Amen? Amen!